December, 1997
OPTIMUM TIMING OF ROUNDUP APPLICATIONS TO RR SOYBEANS
by Donald E. Null, Regional Agronomy Specialist
University Outreach and Extension, NW Region
Objective: The objective of this study was to try to determine the
optimum time to apply Roundup to both wide rowed and drilled
soybeans. Optimization in this study would be measured by soybean
seed yield. The Roundup treatments would also be compared to
common standards used in northwest Missouri.
Methods and Materials: The study was conducted at the Hundley-
Whaley Research Farm at Albany, Missouri. It was designed as a
split block study with 22 treatments. There were 11 herbicide
treatments for each of two row widths. Row widths were 36" and
10". Plot size was 12' wide by 30' long.
Asgrow 3701 soybeans were planted into a conventionally tilled
seedbed on June 2. Wide rowed beans were planted with a 7300 John
Deere vacuum planter at the rate of 180,000 seeds/acre. The 10"
rows were planted with a Tye no-till drill at the rate of 226,000
seeds/acre.
Herbicide treatments are in the table below. DAP represent
"days after planting". All Roundup ultra treatments were at the
rate of 1 quart/acre and each included ammonium sulfate (AMS) at
the rate of 17 pounds/100 gallons of spray solution. All rates our
in product amounts per acre, except additives. They are generally
expressed in percent volume/volume.
Pre-emergence Post-emergence Post-emergence
Treatment/Acre Timing Treatment
-----------------------------------------------------------------
none used 21DAP Roundup Ultra, 1 qt
none used 28DAP Roundup Ultra, 1 qt
none used 35DAP Roundup Ultra, 1 qt
none used 39DAP Roundup Ultra, 1 qt
Prowl 3.3 EC, 2.9 pt 28DAP Pursuit 2 EC, 4 oz +
Status 2 EC, 12 oz + UAN, 1%
and Sunnit II, 1% vol/vol
Authority Broadleaf, 28DAP Roundup Ultra, 12 oz
6.8 oz
none used 21DAP Galaxy, 2 pt +
Poast Plus, 2.25 pt +
Crop Oil Concentrate, 2 pt
none used 21 and 39DAP Roundup Ultra, 1 qt followed
by Roundup Ultra, 1 qt
none used 28DAP Pursuit 2EC, 4 oz +
Status 2EC, 12 oz + UAN, 1%
and Sunnit II, 1% vol/vol
none used 21DAP Pursuit 2EC, 4 oz +
Cobra 2EC, 4 oz + UAN, 1%
and Sunnit II, 1% vol/vol
The weeds present at time of the
post application, and their size is in the table below. These
were not the only weeds in the plot area. Just the major ones or
the ones that were providing a moderate to high pressure. There
was also a light infestation of ivyleaf morningglory and
waterhemp.
Applica
-tion Date ------------- Weeds and Size --------------
Time Applied Grass Sunflower Cocklebur Velvetleaf
------------------------------------------------------------------
21DAP June 23 4-6" tall 4-6" tall 4-6" tall 1-3" tall
June 30 6-8" tall 12-18" tall 10-16" tall 4-8" tall
July 7 8-12" tall 12-20" tall 12-15" tall 12-16" tall
July 11 16-20" tall 24-30" tall 20-28" tall 20-28" tall
July 11 1-2" tall 1-3" tall 2-4" tall 1/2-1" tall
following
June 23
Roundup
------------------------------------------------------------------
*Grasses - approximately 50% giant foxtail and 50% large crabgrass
All herbicide applications were made with a Farmall C tractor
equipped with a front mounted 12" wide boom. Nozzles were wide
angle flat fan delivering 0.2 gallons of spray solution per minute.
Nozzle spacings were 18" on the boom and boom height was adjusted
to be 12" above the tallest plants in the plots. Spray pressure
was 28 p.s.i. and the propellent was compressed air.
The weather at the Hundley-Whaley farm started off wet. Soils
did not dry up until mid-May. It turned off dry after memorial
day. The fist significant rain following planting and pre-emerge
herbicide applications was on June 15 (0.74"), nearly two weeks
after planting. The summer could be charicterized as being dry but
mild. We only received 1.37" of rain in June and 1.83" of rain in
July. Temperatures were in the 70 to 95 degree F for most of that
period. We did experience two days of 100 degree temperatures
(July 25 & 26). It turned off wet again in the fall (after
mid-October) and this delayed harvest.
Weed control ratings were taken at various times during the
year but only the last rating will be reported here.
Harvest was done on November 18 with a Massey Harris Super 35
combine converted to harvest small plots.
Results and Discussion: Dry weather, along with shallow seed
placement in the drilled soybeans, resulted in poor stand of
drilled soybeans. The wide rowed beans did emerge early and
uniformily. The data in this report will only cover the wide rowed
soybeans.
Figure 1 shows the weed control provided by the six Roundup
Ultra treatments in wide rowed soybeans. The best overall weed
control was provided by the split Roundup application. The next
best treatments was the pre-emergence application of Authority
Broadleaf followed by the reduced rate of Roundup. There was no
statistical difference in weed control between these two
treatments. The lack of weed control provided by the 21DAP Roundup
application was due to a new flush of weeds following the initial
application. We would have expected different and better results
in the drilled soybeans if we had had a good stand. The 28 and 35
DAP Roundup applications provided good weed control but the 39DAP
application failed to provided a high level of grass and velvetleaf
control. This 39DAP application did control nearly all of the
giant foxtail but did not control the large crabgrass in the plots.
Figure 1
Figure 2 shows the late weed control ratings of the two best
Roundup treatments, compared to four standard treatments. The best
overall weed control from the standard treatments was provided by
the pre Prowl followed by the 28DAP Pursuit + Status treatment.
The 28DAP Pursuit + Status treatment failed to control the grass
species in the plots. That there was a very significant difference
in the grass control provided by these two treatments was
surprising, given the lack of rainfall following the pre-emergence
Prowl application. The 21DAP Galaxy + Poast Plus treatment failed
to control wild sunflower in this study and the sunflower pressure
was heavy.
Figure 2
Figure 3 graphically illustrates the yield of soybeans for the
Roundup treatments. From a statistical standpoint, there was no
difference in yield from the split Roundup treatment, the Authority
Broadleaf followed by a reduced rate of Roundup, the 21DAP Roundup
treatment and the 28DAP Roundup treatment. The 35 and 39 DAP
treatments yielded significantly less than the other Roundup
treatments.
Figure 3
None of the standard treatments yielded as well as the four
top yielding Roundup treatments. The Galaxy + Poast Plus, Pursuit
+ Cobra and Pursuit + Status treatments each yielded between 20 and
25 bushels per acre. The best yielding standard treatment was the
pre-emergence Prowl followed by the 21 DAP Pursuit + Status treat-
ment. It yielded 36 bu/acre which was statistically the same
soybean yield as provided by the 21 and 28 DAP Roundup alone
treatments. This treatment did yield significanly less than the
split Roundup treatment and the Authority Broadleaf followed by a
reduced rate of Roundup. Figure 4 shows a graph of selected
Roundup treatments compared to the standards.
Figure 4
|