University of Missouri-Columbia
MU Hundley-Whaley Center
Agricultural Experiment Station
College of Agriculture, Food and Natural Resources
Map
Driving directions
Albany, Gentry County

Field Day
*Our annual Field Day will be held August 27, 2008.

FFA Day
*FFA Day will be held September 16, 2008.

Research

Faculty

Facilities/Meetings

Planning Committee

Newsletter

Weather

Variety Performance

LDC Development

Contact us
Bruce Burdick
1109 S. Birch St.
Albany, MO 64402
660-726-5610
Email: BurdickB@missouri.edu

Hundley-Whaley Center phone
660-726-3698

EFFECT OF ULTRA EARLY SOYBEAN PLANTING DATES ON SOYBEAN PRODUCTION ECONOMICS (VERP)

by Donald E. Null, Regional Agronomy Specialist
Sponsored by Missouri Soybean Merchandising Council and Producer Check-off Funds

Situation: The November issue of The Furrow (Volume 104, Issue 7, PP31-32) reported on a story about ultra early soybean planting. Producer David Savage, Farley, Iowa, had planted soybeans in early April, in no-till fields with good results. Larry Lotz, Ohio State University, produced 70 bushels/acre from a March 16 planting. Tom Weiler, Cardington, Ohio believes that very early planting is less risky than double cropping beans behind wheat. The article indicated that no-till residue is partly successful for the success of the practice. Fungicide seed treatments were also touted as important for early planting success. Such a practice, if successful, could be beneficial to northwest Missouri soybean producers. It could spread the workload and possibly lead to increased crop performance.

Methods: The study was designed and analyzed with Gylling's Agriculture Research Manger 6.1 and it consisted of twenty treatments to compare the effect of ultra early planting verses normal planting. Merschman's Houston V RR, a mid-group 4-maturity soybean brand was selected for use in the experiment. The seed was factory treated with Rival and Allegiance fungicides (Captan, PCNB, Thiabendazole and Metalaxy) at manufacturer recommended rates. The row width was 18", which was derived by splitting the rows with a 36" wide John Deere 7100 Max-Emerge, vacuum-type planter. Seeding rate was 225,000 seeds/acre.

The soil was a Grundy Silt Loam with 3.1% O.M. located at the Hundley-Whaley Research Farm, located on a second bottom of the East Fork of Grand River in Gentry county, Missouri. This soil type has a tendency to stay wet when covered with heavy residue. Such was the case at the study site this spring.

The treatments consisted of both no-till and minimum tilled (spring-disked) plots. Planting was done with a 36" row planter set to deliver ½ of the desired seed needed for final planting rate. Following the initial pass across the plot, the tractor and planter then split the rows by placing and driving the tractor wheels on row 2 and 4 of the initial planting. Planting depth was 1-1 ½".

Disking with a tandem disk on March 27 and 28 prior to planting accomplished the tillage in the tilled plots. This was the only time the plots were tilled. After the initial tillage, the conventionally tilled plots were planted into what could be called a "stale seedbed" with emerged weeds controlled by Roundup applications.

The study was planned for the first planting date to be in mid-March. After that, planting would be done at two-week intervals as long as the weather would allow. Planned and actual planting dates are shown in Table 1.

Planned Actual
March 15 March 28
April 1 April 12
April 15 May 2
May 1 May12
May 15 May 30
Table 1

There were no weeds in the tilled or no-till plots at the beginning of the season. Weed control consisted of broadcast applications of Roundup at the rate of 1 quart/acre in a twenty gallon per acre spray solution as needed for weed control. These applications were made April 25, May 19 and June 12 to all plots in the study. The primary weed specie present at each spray application time was 3-5" tall giant foxtail.

Plant counts were taken on June 14 by selecting what looked like representative stands from three different locations in each row and counting the live soybean plants in a three foot section of each row.

The soybeans were mechanically harvested on October 9 with a Massey 35 plot combine. Harvest consisted of harvesting the four center rows of the eight row plots.

Results: The study was initiated on March 28 with the first soybean planting. Plantings were made at approximately two-week intervals following the first planting date. On May 17, a subjective evaluation was made estimating the percent emergence and percent of seedling dampened off for the two most vulnerable and earliest planting date soybeans. The results of this evaluation are found in Table 2.

Soybean Planting
Date
Percent of Planted Soybeans Emerged and Dampened-off on May 17, 2000
Emerged Seedlings Emerged but Dead
No-Till Disked No-Till Disked
March 28 59 90 43 3
April 12 77 80 31 2
LSD 0.05 10 14
Table 2

The results of the plant counts taken on June 14 is found in Table 3. The stand in the early planted soybeans, for both the no-till and disked plots were significantly less than the later planting dates. The poorest stand was obtained in the no-till, March 28 planted soybeans.

Planting
Date
Percent of Full Stand of Soybeans
No-Till Disked
March 28 45 74
April 12 80 88
May 2 94 100
May 12 91 97
May 30 94 100
LSD 0.05 14
Table 3

The soybeans harvest data is found in Table 4 and Figure 1.

Planting
Date
Soybean Yield (Bu/Acre)
No-Till Disked
March 28 36 46
April 12 46 47
May 2 44 44
May 12 41 42
May 30 40 38
LSD 0.05 6
Table 4


Figure 1

Summary: The soil in the no-till plots was actually too wet to plant at all planting dates, despite the very dry spring. This was due to the very heavy giant foxtail residue and the poor internal drainage of this particular soil type. The very early planted no-till plots did delay soybean emergence by 7-10 days. The late March no-till planted soybeans suffered from considerable dampening-off compared to the conventionally tilled soybeans. While the treated seed might have provided some protection from dampening-off organisms, it was not enough.

There was no statistical difference in soybean yields in the disked plots for the planting dates ranging from March 28 through May 12. The highest soybean yield in both the disked and no-till plots was a result of the April 12 planting and this yield was statistically higher than the May 30 planted soybeans. The very early planted no-till soybeans yielded significantly less than the very early soybeans in the disked plots. With the exception of the March 28 planting date, there was no difference in soybean yields between the soybeans in the disked treatments and soybeans in the no-till treatments.

If the practice of very early, no-till soybean planting is to successful, it will likely need to be made on well-drained soils that dry out sooner than the soils in these plots.

The last killing frost occurred on April 12 this year. None of the planted beans had emerged by that time. Consequently there was no frost damage. A late April or early May killing frost could have resulted in a different outcome for the trial.

Outreach: The study was explained in this year's Hundley-Whaley Field Day report. Over 800 copies of the report were distributed to people attending the field day. The data will be shared with northwest Missouri producers at three winter meetings. The data will also be shared with north Missouri producers through newsletters and newspaper articles this winter.

Future Plans: The study will be repeated in 2001, with the approval of funding support from the Missouri Soybean Merchandising Council. However, the study site for 2001 will be moved to a better-drained area of the farm.


The Missouri Agricultural Experiment Station is the research arm of the
College of Agriculture, Food and Natural Resources
at the University of Missouri-Columbia
Site maintained by people at AgEBB

agebb@missouri.edu